PACKETPERF

Primary Device

Cisco Secure Firewall 3110
Cisco Secure Firewall 3110
★ 3.3 Value Score

Technical Specifications

  • Firewall Throughput: 17 Gbps (FW + AVC, 1024B, FTD); 18 Gbps stateful inspection (ASA)
  • Threat Prevention Throughput: 17 Gbps (FW + AVC + IPS, 1024B, FTD); 17 Gbps NGIPS (1024B, FTD)
  • IPsec VPN Throughput: 8 Gbps (1024B TCP w/ FastPath, FTD); 8 Gbps (450B UDP L2L, ASA); up to 11 Gbps projected with VPN offload (FTD 7.2)
  • Max Sessions: 2,000,000 concurrent (with AVC, FTD); 2,000,000 concurrent firewall connections (ASA)
  • New Sessions/sec: 130,000 (with AVC, FTD); 300,000 (ASA)
  • Interfaces: 8 x 10M/100M/1GBASE-T RJ-45; 8 x 1/10G SFP+; 1 x 1/10G SFP management port; optional 8 x 1/10G network module (up to 24 Ethernet ports total)
  • Form Factor: 1U rack-mount (1.75 x 17 x 20 in)

Curation Review

  • ✔ Pros: 17 Gbps FW+AVC and NGIPS throughput on FTD, a large step up from the 1000 series; 2 million concurrent sessions and 130,000 new connections/sec with AVC on FTD; 8 x 1G RJ-45 plus 8 x 1/10G SFP+ ports give 10GbE uplink options; 8 Gbps IPsec VPN (up to 11 Gbps with offload) with up to 3,000 VPN peers; Runs FTD or ASA software and is managed through Firewall Management Center or Firewall Device Manager
  • ✘ Cons: High cost for the class, with new-unit listings around $17k to $22k and list prices above $65k; New connections/sec on FTD (130,000) is less than half the ASA figure (300,000); Threat prevention and support require separate paid licensing; Reseller listings mix ASA and FTD figures (some quote 45 Gbps firewall throughput) that do not match Cisco's datasheet, so the software image must be checked; Pricing varies widely and some listings are out of stock, so current availability and end-of-sale status should be verified with a Cisco partner
  • Est. Price: $16,737 - $22,347

Compare Against

Ubiquiti UniFi Dream Machine Pro Max
Ubiquiti UniFi Dream Machine Pro Max
★ 5.0 Value Score

Technical Specifications

  • Firewall Throughput: Not published by Ubiquiti. Third-party tests: about 3.8-4.7 Gbps internet (WAN) throughput; about 3.0 Gbps inter-VLAN routing
  • Threat Prevention Throughput: 5 Gbps IDS/IPS (Ubiquiti spec)
  • IPsec VPN Throughput: Not published by Ubiquiti. Unverified third-party estimate of about 1.8-2.2 Gbps
  • Max Sessions: Not published
  • New Sessions/sec: Not published
  • Interfaces: 2x 10G SFP+ ports; 8x 1GbE RJ45 LAN ports; 1x 2.5GbE RJ45 WAN port (sources conflict on WAN; one lists a 25GbE WAN port)
  • Form Factor: 1U rackmount

Curation Review

  • ✔ Pros: 5 Gbps IDS/IPS rating from Ubiquiti; 10G SFP+ ports for fast uplinks or LAN; Multi-WAN support with 2.5GbE WAN; Integrated UniFi Network controller and UniFi OS for centralized management; Built-in NVR bay for UniFi Protect cameras; Rackmount 1U form factor suited to server racks
  • ✘ Cons: Ubiquiti does not publish firewall, VPN, or session-rate figures; Real-world WAN throughput in independent tests is about 3-4.7 Gbps, below the 5 Gbps IDS/IPS rating; Port layout and WAN specs differ between sources; Costs about 2x the UDM Pro (about $220 more) for a modest throughput gain; Limited 1GbE LAN port count compared with dedicated switches; Requires UniFi ecosystem for full feature set
  • Est. Price: $599 - $660

Popular Comparisons

Cisco Secure Firewall 3110 vs Ubiquiti UniFi Cloud Gateway Fiber Cisco Secure Firewall 3110 vs Ubiquiti UniFi Dream Machine Pro Max Cisco Secure Firewall 3110 vs Ubiquiti Cloud Gateway Max Cisco Secure Firewall 3110 vs Ubiquiti UniFi Cloud Gateway Max (UCG-Max) Cisco Secure Firewall 3110 vs Ubiquiti Enterprise Fortress Gateway (EFG)